Answer
The Old Testament contains one verse that says Jesus is like the only son and like the first-born for the Jews in Jerusalem!
But there is no sense of Him actually being created!
Explanation
In fact this is a prophecy for the future in Prophet Zechariah’s book. Let us see that:
“And I will pour on the house of David, and on those living in
Jerusalem, the Spirit of grace and of prayers. And they shall look
on Me whom they have pierced; and they shall mourn for Him, as one
mourns for an only son, and they shall be bitter over Him, like
the bitterness over the FIRST-BORN” (Zech 12:10).
This is Yahweh speaking. He says they shall look upon Me (Yahweh) whom they have pierced. But actually in history it was Jesus who was pierced.
So we see all the things clearly together here:
Jesus Christ (Yahweh pierced), only Son (only begotten) and First-born (prototokos).
But we do not see any implication that Jesus (Yahweh) is created in Zechariah 12:10.
So, 460 years before itself, Yahweh has made it abundantly clear that He will be incarnated, pierced and will be considered as the Only Son and the First-born!
Jesus is never created
Jesus is never created.
Proof # 1: -
“And again, when He brought the First-born into the world, He
said, "And let all the angels of God worship Him" (Heb 1:6).
If Jesus was a created being, then he is not and cannot be the first-born, simply because angels were existing before him!
Let us read it again: when God the Father created and brought the first-born Jesus into existence, angels were already around to obey God and worship Jesus.
But, the Unitarians claim that Jesus created “all (other) things”! [‘other’ is added by them; it is not in the Scripture].
This is a contradiction and an unsolvable vicious circle.
Jesus needs to be the first-created. So, no angels should be around because Jesus is supposed to be creating the angels. However, when the Father created and brought His first-created son, by mistake, all angels were around to worship him.
Proof # 2:-
“because whom He foreknew, He also predestinated to be conformed to
the image of His Son, for Him TO BE the First-born among many
brothers” (Rom 8:29).
What?!
If Jesus is the first-created, then it doesn’t matter whether others are conformed to Him or not. Even if others are not around, still Jesus will be the first-created.
But here the Scripture states that God the Father foreknew some, predestinated them to be conformed to Jesus SO THAT Jesus WOULD BECOME the First-born among many brothers!
So, if brothers are not around, Jesus cannot be the First-born and the first-created!
Proof # 3:-
“But you have come……… to the general assembly and church of the
first-born who are written in Heaven………and to Jesus” (Heb 12:22-24).
Church of the first-born simply means church of the saints who are called out. But we know that the saints cannot be the first-born because Adam was the first-created human being. The saints are not the first-borns/ first-created
.
So, it becomes very clear that church of the first-born means the church of the saints who are going to be resurrected from the dead as the first-fruit of the entire humanity (James 1:18).
That’s it!
Jesus is called First-born because He is the first One ever to break the shackles of death and be resurrected to eternal life from among the dead!
First-born ≠ First-created but
First-born = First-resurrected
First-born does NOT mean first-created. The Scripture says otherwise!
Hebrew 12:23 talks about “the church of the first-born ones”.
These first-born saints in the church CANNOT BE FIRST-CREATED ONES because the Scripture says ADAM AND EVE ARE THE FIRST-CREATED ONES.
This proves beyond any doubt that first-born does not and cannot mean first-created.
Same way, when Jesus is called the First-born, He is NOT the first created. He is the Creator because without Him nothing was created as per the same Scripture.
First-born means resurrected from the dead as shown below:
“for Him to be the First-born among many brothers” (Rom 8:29).
“And He is the Head of the body, the church, who is the Beginning, the
First-born from the dead, that He may be pre-eminent in all
things” (Col 1:18).
“even from Jesus Christ the faithful Witness, the First-born from
the dead” (Rev 1:5).
Let the Scripture define and qualify its own term.
Col. 1:15 - First-born of all creation?
There is no need for people to jump to hasty conclusions. They think that Jesus is the first ever creature by God the Father when the verse doesn’t say anything of that sort.
We can see that some versions have the same as “the firstborn of every creature”.
So, what exactly is this reference, “all creation”, “every creature” alluding to? Is it referring to the Genesis creation of the heavens and the earth?
Not at all!
The “all creation” or “every creature” in Greek is “pas ktisis”. "Pas ktisis" is always related to "human beings".
It has nothing to do with Genesis creation of everything.
So, Jesus cannot be the first ever creature when God the Father has made nothing without Jesus Christ:
“All things came into being through Him, and without Him not even
one thing came into being that has come into being” (John 1:3).
[I have never seen any verse in the Scripture as powerfully stated as this!]
All creation/every creature [pas ktisis] = human beings
In fact, Scripture refers “pas ktisis” in reference to human beings as I will prove below:
Evidence # 1
“And He said to them, Going into all the world, preach the gospel to
all the creation [pas ktisis]” (Mark 16:15).
This is Jesus’ final command to His disciples. Yet we know that the apostles never preached the Gospel to mountains, oceans, dogs or animals!
They preached the Gospel only to human beings (all creation/ every creature/ pas ktisis).
Evidence # 2
“However, you must remain firmly established and steadfast in the
faith, without being moved from the hope of the gospel that you heard,
which has been proclaimed to every creature (pas ktisis) under
heaven and of which I, Paul, have become a servant” (Col 1:23).
The Colossians heard the gospel being preached to “every creature/ all creation/ pas ktisis” of which Paul became a servant.
Yet we know that neither the Twelve apostles nor Paul ever preached the gospel to any inanimate creation or animals. It was preached only to human beings.
So, Jesus is the Firstborn from among the human beings who are all destined to die. This is why the Scripture calls Him as the First-born from the dead.
First-born = First-fruit
Jesus is called the First-born in the sense that He is the First-fruit from the dead humans.
“But now Christ has risen from the dead, and has become the
firstfruit of those who slept” (1 Cor 15:20).
“But each in his own order: Christ the first-fruit, and afterward they
who are Christ's at His coming” (verse 23). The latter are called “a
kind of firstfruits of His creatures” (James 1:18).
Now, the conclusion
Conclusion
The saints are called “the church of the first-borns” (Heb 12:23) though none of them are created before Adam and Eve. They are called “first-fruits” of human beings, though none of them preceded Adam or Eve.
Thus, we learn that first-born simply means first-fruit from the dead.
So, Jesus Christ as the First-fruit of the first-fruits = First-born of the first-borns FROM THE DEAD HUMANITY.
Neither the pre-Incarnated Yahweh nor the Incarnated Jesus (both are the same Person) is created.