Where did the idea that the law was administered through angels come from?

Question

The idea that the law was given through angels seems common enough in the first century literature:

Galatians 3:19

Why then the law? It was added because of transgressions, until the offspring should come to whom the promise had been made, and it was put in place through angels by an intermediary.

Acts 7:53

you who have received the law that was given through angels but have not obeyed it.

Hebrews 2:2

For since the message spoken through angels was binding, and every violation and disobedience received its just punishment...

Possibly in Josephus's Antiquities of the Jews XV:163

And for ourselves, we have learned from God the most excellent of our doctrines, and the most holy part of our law, by angels or ambassadors

There is no mention (at least in the translations I checked) of angels in Exodus 19 when the law is given at Sinai. So where does this idea come from? Are there other references to this tradition?

Answer 1

Divine agency

In many Ancient Near Eastern cultures, there was a political concept we call 'agency'. In this, the delegate or ambassador of a god simply spoke in the first person on that god's behalf. The use of agency is only touched on rarely in the broader historical narrative of Genesis–2 Kings, where we sometimes find the Messenger of YHWH speaking about YHWH in the first person.¹ Two occasions where this agency concept are found most explicitly are:

"Behold, I send an angel before you to guard you on the way and to bring you to the place that I have prepared. Pay careful attention to him and obey his voice; do not rebel against him, for he will not pardon your transgression, for my name is in him. But if you carefully obey his voice and do all that I say, then I will be an enemy to your enemies and an adversary to your adversaries." (Exodus 23.20-22, ESV translation)

God's name (authority) is in the angel, and when the angel speaks, it is God's words.

Now the angel of the LORD went up from Gilgal to Bochim. And he said, "I brought you up from Egypt and brought you into the land that I swore to give to your fathers. I said, 'I will never break my covenant with you...'" (Judges 2.1, ESV translation)

The angel speaks, but his words are God's words.

---

Growing interest in angels

Today's critical scholarship generally agrees that the Genesis–2 Kings narrative was compiled and finalized sometime during or shortly after the Babylonian exile. (Second Kings concludes circa 560 BC.) After the exilic period, during the Second Temple era, we find Jewish literature become increasingly interested in heavenly politics and the role of angels.

This is especially the case in the apocalyptic genre. Whereas the earlier prophets claimed to receive their revelations directly from God ('the word of YHWH came to me', 'thus says YHWH', etc.), the Second Temple literature sees a drastic increase in angelic mediators of these revelations (Zechariah, 1 Enoch, Daniel, to name a few).

It's possible that sometime during this Second Temple period, the growing view that God delegated everything through his angels was read backward into those 'agency' seeds of thought found in the biblical narrative. In this way, readers inferred that God must have revealed the Law through an angelic mediator.

---

The Book of Jubilees

One such Second Temple text was the Book of Jubilees, a retelling of the Genesis-Exodus narrative written sometime in the second century BC.

It is in this book, perhaps, that we find the earliest references to the idea that God gave the Law to Moses through an angelic mediator:²

And [God] said to the angel of the presence, "Write for Moses . . ." (Jubilees 1.27)

And the angel of the presence spoke to Moses according to the word of the Lord, saying, "Write the complete history of the creation, how in six days the Lord God finished all his works and all that he created, and kept Sabbath on the seventh day and hallowed it for all ages . . ." (2.1)

Several more times throughout the book, this angel speaks in the first person:

"I have written in the book of the first law, in that which I have written for you . . ." (6.22)

"For this reason I have written for you in the words of the Law . . ." (30.12)

"All this account I have written for you . . ." (30.21)

"And behold the commandment regarding the Sabbaths — I have written them down for you . . ." (50.6)

". . . as it is written in the tablets, which [God] gave into my hands that I should write out for you the laws of the seasons . . ." (50.13)

Evidently, by the middle of the first century AD, this concept had become commonplace, at least among the Christian sect.

---

Footnotes

¹ For a substantial treatment of this concept as it relates to the Messenger of YHWH, see: René A. López, Identifying the "Angel of the Lord" in the Book of Judges: A Model for Reconsidering the Referent in Other Old Testament Loci.

² The following quotations from Jubilees have been adapted from the R.H. Charles translation.

Answer 2

In part, this is derived from Deut. 33:2 and Psa. 68:17.

In Deut. 33:2, it is written,

And he said, "Yahveh came from Sinai, and He rose up from Seir to them; He shined forth from mount Paran, and He came with ten thousands of holy ones; from His right hand, a fiery law for them."

וַיֹּאמַר יַהְוֶה מִסִּינַי בָּא וְזָרַח מִשֵּׂעִיר לָמֹו הֹופִיעַ מֵהַר פָּארָן וְאָתָה מֵרִבְבֹת קֹדֶשׁ מִימִינֹו אשֶׂדת לָֽמֹו

Regarding the phrase מרבבות קדש, "ten thousands of holy ones," Rabbi Avraham ibn Ezra wrote הם המלאכים, that is, "They are the angels." Furthermore, he says that the phrase אשֶׂדת ("fiery law") refers to the Torah [of Moshe] which was given באש וברק, "with fire and lightning" (cp. Exo. 19:16-18).

---

In Psa. 68:17, it is written,

The chariots of God are twenty thousands upon thousands. The Lord is among them in the holy place of Sinai.

רֶכֶב אֱלֹהִים רִבֹּתַיִם אַלְפֵי שִׁנְאָן אֲדֹנָי בָם סִינַי בַּקֹּדֶשׁ

Answer 3

The Hebrew Scriptures identify human beings as temporarily "lower" than the angels (e.g. Ps 8:5, although some translations take the meaning as "lower than God"). Moreover, the OT repeatedly depict angels as purveyors of divine revelation; the term "angel" itself means messenger. That is a very general picture, which James B. Jordan buttresses further by arguing that the serpent who tempted Adam and Eve was an embodiment of the great angel Lucifer, who was sent, not to tempt them, but to instruct them. Instead, he seized his chance to defeat those who were destined to rule over all of God's creation (including angels), but that is another story. Nonetheless, it does make sense of why there is a talking serpent in Eden.

In terms of more specific rationale, Jacob's dream at Bethel was of a ladder between earth and heaven, being ascended and descended by angels (Gen 28:12). He thus identified this place as the house of God and the gate of heaven (Gen 28:17), and made vows that Yahweh would be his God, using language reminiscent of how God later led Israel through the wilderness (28:20–21). Given such connections, it would certainly not be surprising to think that later interpreters made a connection between that Bethel and Mount Sinai, and therefore inferred angelic involvement in God's self-revelation at the latter.

Whatever the source of Paul's notion that the law was given through angels, he certainly held the view in common with others, both in the NT (see e.g. Acts 7:53) and beyond.

Answer 4

It is always God who reveals Himself and speaks to Moses and to the prophets. However, if we take a close look, we may find that even though God is speaking and being addressed as God, He really is represented by His messenger who speaks in His Name and with His authority.

The mention of God´s Angel in Moses´ encounter with God in the burning thornbush teaches us that, while we are careful and eager to make the proper distinctions between Angel and God, the bible and Moses and prophets and apostles are not, at least: not always. (Revelation´s 22:8,9 "I, John, am the one who heard and saw these things. And when I had heard and seen them, I fell down to worship at the feet of the angel who had been showing them to me. But he said to me, "Don't do that! I am a fellow servant with you and with your fellow prophets and with all who keep the words of this scroll. Worship God!" is really an exception in regard to encounters of humans with an angel because the angel here introduced himself as servant angel and not as ambassador in God´s glory. In most other instances (e.g. Exodus 3) it is quite different.

There is no jealousy of God against honour and adoration given to his beloved Sons when they represent His Majesty.

To assume that the Creator of sun and stars should somehow bodily be limited to a - even if burning - thornbush, must have striked impossible not alone to Moses. This, however, did not prevent him from solemn adoration. If, in the end, God shall be All and Everything for All, it would seem very narrow and restrictive to view not His Angels as carrying His Name and Authority rightfully.

(It is impressive and good for us to find that the development of thought in the scriptures does not always follow our lines.)

Answer 5

The new testament ἄγγελος can mean messenger. For example, in Revelation Jesus says to the angel of the church of xxx write. This can mean either write this to the pastor or a guardian angel over the church. So here when it says The Law was instituted through the work of angels, could it possible mean the work of prophets? Clearly it was administered through the Prophet Moses and the Levitical Priesthood. It seems more of a stretch to go for the other obvious meaning, more common in English, ἄγγελος meaning heavenly angel.

Answer 6

Exodus chapters 19-23, etc. have God speaking to Moses and giving him ordinances of the Law of Moses, beginning with the first ten commandments. Note that it is neither the angels nor an angel in view who are / is speaking to Moses in this passage as some contend because they have falsely determined that the Hebrew word transliterated "?l?h?m" is to be translated "angels." The Hebrew word transliterated "?l?h?m" which is plural appears in Ex 20:1 with the Hebrew word transliterated "waydabb?r" rendered "and He spoke," singular which only makes sense if it is referring to God Who is referred to in plurality and is customarily accompanied by a singular verb. It cannot refer to angels, plural with a singular verb. Furthermore, angels cannot be referred to because the context of God speaking to Moses in Exodus chapters 19-23 is clearly established by the Hebrew word "y?h?wh" rendered LORD in chapter 19:5. The word "?l?h?m" can only be translated as God or the LORD God when it is accompanied by "y?h?wh" as it repeatedly appears in this 5 chapter passage. So the Hebrew word "?l?h?m" beginning with 20:2, 5, 7, 10, 12 etc., etc, especially when it appears with "y?h?wh," i.e., "y?h?wh ?l?heyk?" must be translated the LORD your God. This phrase cannot refer to angels at all as the One speaking to Moses and providing details of the Law to him. Angels are neither God, gods nor LORD. Neverthless, angels did participate with God in giving the Law to the mediator, Moses as was previously determined for the people Israel. Note that "the Angel of the Lord" can be determined to be the LORD God appearing in angelic form, and not a finite angel by virtue of a careful reading of the context of the passages that contain this phrase, attributing Him with terms reserved for God alone or attributes of God that exclude angels. The passages that stipulate that angels gave the Law to a mediator do not use the phrase "Angel of the LORD."

Throughout the history of the world - of creation from the very beginning of when God created angelic beings, angels have participated with and for God in His ministrations with mankind. Since the Word of God does not cover every moment and event in the lives of the people of God or any other group of people, or persons; and since it is a limited number of recorded events and teachings throughout a period of thousands of years of the history of mankind; then the rest of those moments not so recorded in Scripture includes innumerable accounts which evidently involve angelic ministrations under the direction of the LORD God to the people of God, in view of the many citations of such involvement in Scripture already stipulated and more, in coordination with God's efforts to instruct Moses in the ordinances of the Law and Moses' administration / mediation of that Law to the people of Israel. R

Answer 7

The idea that the law was given by angels is Gnostic in origin.

Both Simon and Saturninus state that the Old Testament prophecies were inspired by angels. Simon specifically says that they gave the Old Testament law, while Saturninus adds that some of the prophecies came from Satan.

Grant, R. M. (1959). Gnosticism and early Christianity. New York: Columbia University Press. page 16