There is Evidence for Two Periods without Reference to Dan 9
Introductory Comments
- A Commitment: To abide by the parameters you have set (at least as I understand them), specifically avoiding in the main argument reference to Daniel 9 and the 70th week. Of course, it is always dangerous to purposefully "exclude" any part of God's Revelation in coming to understand the meaning of texts. That exclusion may hold the one key to a correct interpretation. However, I believe in this case your question can be answered without it (just perhaps not in full detail).
- A Disclaimer: I am a Dispensationalist.
- A Clarification: The “Darbian/Dispensational view” is not itself “applied as a hermeneutic,” but rather is a theology that derives from a grammatical-historical hermeneutic, a theology that works very diligently to have conclusions “based on the text itself.” I hope to demonstrate some of that here, as such is the hermeneutic that I will be following.
- Some Assumptions: We will assume here (as you have, and I think rightly) that the “time and times and half a time” are a reference to 3 1/2 years just as the other numerical references are, and that such numbers are to be taken literally (there are hermeneutics that do not take numbers literally). Additionally, it is assumed here that the trumpet soundings of Revelation are sequential, one following the other (not all hold to this either)—this is actually demonstrated by other factors in the argument below, but to avoid need of proving it more fully, it will be assumed. Finally, the view taken here is a futurist view, that the events are describing things not only future at the time of their being prophesied, but still future as of the posting of this answer (other hermeneutics will derive a different conclusion on this as well).
- Of the translation: All quoted text is from NKJV (unless otherwise noted), and emphasized text or summarized concepts is deemed more relevant to the question at hand.
The Argument
Daniel 7
Summary of Critical Points to the Question
The fourth beast (Dan 7:7) was the fourth and final kingdom (7:23) prophesied to Daniel. From within this fourth kingdom were 10 horns (7:8) which were kings (7:24), 3 of which are removed or subdued before a little horn (king) who rises (7:8, 20, 24). This little horn is most characterized by the fact that he has “a mouth speaking pompous words” (7:8; cf. v.11, 20, 25). It is also this little horn that “was making war against the saints, and prevailing against them,” (7:21) for a period of “a time and times and half a time” (7:25), which prevailing lasts only “until the Ancient of Days came” (7:22).
Commentary on Timing
This information locates the 3 1/2 years as the final time up to the coming of the Ancient of Days, a period in which the saints are losing the battle here on earth. This then is the final 3 1/2 years before God takes direct rule back.
Daniel 11-12
Summary of Critical Points to the Question
The position of “king of the North” changes hands twice rapidly in Dan 11:19-21, the second time being taken by “a vile person” (11:21), who then goes against the long time foe of the (position of the) king of the North, “the king of the South,” and the North prevails (11:25). Of this new vile person that is now the king of the North it is said that “his heart shall be moved against the holy covenant” (11:28-29) and favor those who forsake it (11:30, 32), and he defiles the sanctuary, stops sacrifices, and places the abomination of desolation there (11:31), and those “who know their God … shall fall by sword and flame, by captivity and plundering” (11:33), all of which “until the time of the end,” so only for “the appointed time” (11:35). During this time this king “shall exalt and magnify himself above every god, shall speak blasphemies against the God of gods, and shall prosper till the wrath has been accomplished” (11:36). Forsaking God, exalting self, but honoring a new unknown god (11:37-38). When it is time for this king’s end (11:45), “At that time Michael shall stand up, the great prince who stands watch over the sons of your [Daniel’s] people … and at that time your people shall be delivered” (12:1), but immediately before Michael’s standing and delivering, even up “to that time” is “a time of trouble such as never was since there was a nation” (12:1), which refers back to that period of their falling before the end (11:33-35). One asks how long is this period of trouble until the time Michael stands at the end (12:6), to which the reply is “a time, times, and half a time.” The trouble only finishing once it is true that “the power of the holy people has been completely shattered” (12:7).
[NOTE: Two other time measures are given following these verses: (1) “from the time that the daily sacrifice is taken away, and the abomination of desolation is set up” is “one thousand two hundred and ninety days” (12:11), and (2) “Blessed is he who waits, and comes to the one thousand three hundred and thirty-five days” (12:12). Answering the relation of these times to the 3 1/2 years is outside the scope of this question, but it is obvious that they are not referring to the exact same 1260 days, though overlap is certainly occurring.]
Commentary on Timing
[Brief Excursus: It seems quite likely to me that this vile person who has the two previous kings of the North die before his ascension, and the one king of the South he takes out himself, are the 3 kings that fall because of him. Of course only the final of the three is flatly stated to be subdued by this vile person, but the rather oblique language used for the fall of the first king of the North, along with the short reign of the second who also has his death rather obliquely referred to could well relate to the “intrigue” of how the vile person seizes the kingdom (11:19-21).]
The identification of these three fallen kings in Dan 11 with those of Dan 7 need not be correct to still recognize that the identity of this new king of the North, the vile person, is the same as the “little horn” from Dan 7, for it is this king that has the same pompous spirit and words as that which so characterized the “little horn” king of Dan 7. Before the time of this vile person's end when Michael is standing to deliver Daniel’s people is this great time of trouble, that spans from the abomination of desolation (11:31) to the end (11:35, 45). A period we are told is this 3 1/2 years (12:7).
This information locates the 3 1/2 years of trouble being from the abomination of desolation up to the end time of the standing of Michael the great prince, a period in which those who know their God are losing the battle here on earth. This is then the same time as Dan 7 refers to, the time right before God takes direct rule back.
Revelation 11:1-14 (some notations back to 9)
Summary of Critical Points to the Question
The temple of God is present, with altar, and some are worshiping there, but the city itself is overrun by Gentiles, for the time of “forty-two months” (11:1-2), and two witnesses of God “prophesy one thousand two hundred and sixty days” (11:3). It is not until “they finish their testimony” that “the beast that ascends out of the bottomless pit will make war against them, overcome them, and kill them” (11:7). After they rise again in 3 1/2 days (11:9, 11), ascend to heaven (v.12), and an earthquake destroys part of the city (v.13), the second woe is said to be past, and the third coming soon (v.14).
Commentary on Timing
This information locates the 3 1/2 years during a time when the temple of God still exists and worshipers of God are gathering therein (i.e. the abomination of desolation is not set up), and in which the war against God’s people is not yet occurring, only beginning at the end of it. This is then NOT the same 3 1/2 year time as that right before God is taking direct rule back. Note that a confirmatory contextual clue to this is that these events are occurring within the 6th trumpet sounding, with one trumpet sounding to follow where other events are noted.
Revelation 11:15-12:13
Summary of Critical Points to the Question
During the 7th trumpet sounding (11:15), sometime after a woman’s child destined to rule all nations is “caught up to God and His throne,” (12:5) something compels the woman to flee “into the wilderness,” where God has made preparations for her sustenance that will last “o*ne thousand two hundred and sixty days*” (12:6), or “a time and times and half” (12:14). This time, however, does not occur until after the dragon who sought the child (12:4) had been cast out from heaven and down to the earth (12:9). This casting to earth is a “Woe to the inhabitants of the earth and the sea!” (12:12), and having been cast down to the earth, in his wrath he persecutes the woman (12:12-13). It is then that the woman takes her flight (12:6, 14). The dragon attempts to get her, but cannot, and instead goes “to make war with the rest of her offspring, who keep the commandments of God and have the testimony of Jesus Christ” (12:17).
Commentary on Timing
This information locates the beginning of the 3 1/2 years in conjunction with a time of persecution for the woman, from which she flees, but her offspring are instead made war with during this same time she is away in the wilderness. It is also located in the 7th trumpet sounding, after the events of Rev 11:1-14. This is then the same time as that right before God is taking direct rule back as Dan 7 and 11-12.
Revelation 13
Summary of Critical Points to the Question
The dragon gives power to a beast (13:1-2), one with “a blasphemous name” (v.1). A miraculous healing occurs to this beast, and many follow him because of it (13:3), worshiping both him and the dragon (13:4). This beast “was given a mouth speaking great things and blasphemies” and also “given authority to continue for forty-two months” (13:5). His blasphemies were “against God … His name, His tabernacle, and those who dwell in heaven” (13:6). The authority included “to make war with the saints and to overcome them” (13:7).
Commentary on Timing
This information locates the 3 1/2 years in conjunction with the beast’s speaking of blasphemies against God and making war against the saints, to the point of overcoming them. This is the same language of Dan 7 and 11-12, and Rev 12, and thus is then the same time as that right before God is taking direct rule back.
The Conclusion: An Answer to Your Questions Exists
Yes, there is evidence derived from the context of the specified texts you noted which points to two separate periods, and thus there is something “in the text to suggest the multiple references are NOT to a single 3 and 1/2 year period.”
First 3 1/2 Years: Based on circumstances of Rev 11:1-14, the 3 1/2 years there (11:2, 3) precedes the abomination of the temple, and the making of war against the saints.
Second 3 1/2 Years: All other references (Dan 7:25; 12:7; Rev 12:6, 14; 13:5) are to a period of 3 1/2 years after the abomination, during which time the "little horn/vile person king of the North/beast empowered by the dragon" person speaks blasphemy and pompous words while making war with the saints.
The evidence noted does indicate the first period is not separated from the second period by much (if any), but does not clearly indicate (that I can tell) an immediate succession from one period to the next. So from the above argument your questions answer out as:
- “Do the periods in Revelation refer to the same period of 3 and 1/2 years?” No
- “Multiple periods of 3 1/2 years?” Yes
- “Two halves of a 7 year period?” Possibly
- “Or something else?” Not likely
- “Is there anything in the text to suggest the multiple references are NOT to a single 3 and 1/2 year period?” Yes