3

In Matt 9:36-38 (NIV) reads

36 When he saw the crowds, he had compassion on them, because they were harassed and helpless, like sheep without a shepherd. 37 Then he said to his disciples, “The harvest is plentiful but the workers are few. 38 Ask the Lord of the harvest, therefore, to send out workers into his harvest field.”

Is there a mixed metaphor here? Why not say something like, "Ask the Lord of the flock to send out shepherds into his flock?

2
  • 2
    You are crying over split hairs. My advice is don’t count your chickens before they are sour grapes!
    – Kris
    Nov 29 '21 at 1:09
  • 1
    Check original texts... Each translation of the Bible could be different. You could for example have a "mixed metaphor" aspiration of the Bible, in theory. Good for pen-testing one's interpretation and understanding perhaps on the RedLetters Nov 29 '21 at 6:31
12

First point, it was the apostle Matthew who reported Jesus' compassion for the weary multitudes who appeared (spiritually) as sheep having no shepherd. Then Matthew reports Jesus' actual words that all his disciples need to heed when they view spiritually weary multitudes - "Pray ye therefore the Lord of the harvest, that he will send forth labourers into his harvest" (JKV).

If you wanted a biblical example of Jesus mixing his metaphors, you should have quoted what he said in John's gospel account: "I am the light of the world... I am the way, the truth and the life" (John chapter 8); "I am the door of the sheep... I am the good shepherd... My sheep hear my voice" (John chapter 10); "I am the true vine and my Father is the husbandman" (John chapter 15).

So, the answer to your question is that the example you give in Matthew 9:36-39 is not really Jesus mixing his metaphors because he only states one metaphor. Matthew wrote the other one.

But given how much Jesus mixed his metaphors as in those examples in John's account above, the answer is "Yes, Jesus frequently mixed his metaphors." It's not a sin to mix your metaphors (in case you're wondering).

As for the suggestion you offer in your closing sentence, Jesus himself says he is the good shepherd, his sheep knowing his voice and following him. They will not follow hired under-shepherds (John 10:1-5). The metaphors Jesus employs are appropriate for the context in which he states each of them. He was speaking to people working in agriculture, working with flocks, and fishing. He used different metaphors for specific purposes, and when he mixed his metaphors, those who knew and believed his teaching would appreciate the application of them all.

1
  • 1
    Good point on Matthew's description vs. Jesus' statement. For the examples from John 8, 10 and 15, these were metaphors given at different times. There's no problem with describing something in different ways. In the example I gave, it whas the proximal temporal sequence that made it sound (to me) like a single statement in two parts, with a switch of metaphors midway.
    – blearyeye
    Nov 29 '21 at 14:47
1

The Bible writers and Jesus often mixed metaphors and the OP has listed a prime example. Here is another example from the writing of Paul in 1 Cor 3 -

  • V1, 2 - Paul uses the metaphor of infants drinking milk
  • V3 - metaphor of a walk compared to the Christian life
  • V6, 7 - church compared to a plants in a farm being watered and harvested
  • V8 - Christians compared with a labor force
  • V9 - Christians compared with bricks in a building
  • V10 - Christ is the cornerstone

Even in the sayings of Jesus, metaphor proliferate, and are so common that those familiar with the Bible language stop noticing them. Here is a sample:

  • Matt 5:19 - disciples compared to fishermen and people compared to fish
  • Matt 5:13 - people compared to salt
  • Matt 5:14 - people compared to lamps and then a city on a hill in the same sentence
  • Matt 5:15, 16 - good works compared to light
  • Matt 6:19 - Christian life and morals is compared to treasure
  • Matt 6:22 - the eye compared to a lamp
  • Matt 6:24 - money compared to a taskmaster
  • Matt 6:25-32 - people compared to birds, then flowers, then grass, then judgement to a furnace, etc.
  • Matt 7:3-5 - people's judgement compared to planks and sawdust
  • Matt 7:6 - people compared to dogs and pigs
  • Matt 7:9 - God the Father compared to an earthly father
  • Matt 7:13, 14 - people's decisions compared to gates
  • Matt 7:15 - prophets compared to disguised wolves hunting sheep
  • Matt 7:24ff - Jesus' teaching compared to a building and its foundations

... and so forth. Earlier in the same chapter of Matt 9 we have another series of three metaphors to teach the same idea:

  • Matt 9:15 - Jesus and Christians compared to the guests and the bridegroom at a wedding
  • Matt 9:16 - Christians compared to a repair of a garment
  • Matt 9:17, 18 - Christians compared to wine and wineskins

Thus, mixing metaphors is extremely common in Scripture.

0

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.