2

There seems to be a disagreement between the gospels of Luke and Matthew regarding the location of the first appearance of the resurrected Jesus to the eleven disciples.

The author of Luke states, Luke 24:

33 And they rose that same hour and returned to Jerusalem. And they found the eleven and those who were with them gathered together, 34 saying, “The Lord has risen indeed, and has appeared to Simon!” 35 Then they told what had happened on the road, and how he was known to them in the breaking of the bread.

36 As they were talking about these things, Jesus himself stood among them, and said to them, “Peace to you!” 37 But they were startled and frightened and thought they saw a spirit. 38 And he said to them, “Why are you troubled, and why do doubts arise in your hearts? 39 See my hands and my feet, that it is I myself. Touch me, and see. For a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see that I have.” 40 And when he had said this, he showed them his hands and his feet. 41 And while they still disbelieved for joy and were marveling, he said to them, “Have you anything here to eat?” 42 They gave him a piece of broiled fish, 43 and he took it and ate before them.

Verse 33 starts with two disciples relating their encounter with a post-resurrection Jesus to the eleven upon meeting them in Jerusalem. Via the use of the word "indeed" by the two disciples in verse 34 we can deduce that the eleven were unconvinced of the resurrection during this time.

So how are we to know this is their first time witnessing post-resurrected Jesus? Well, they are:

  1. Startled and frightened, thinking they had seen a spirit
  2. Troubled and doubtful of the risen Jesus
  3. Jesus tries to reassure them -- he shows them his mutilated hands and feet, compels them to touch him, and ate before them.

These are not the signs of people who had previously seen the risen Jesus. The author of Luke clearly tries to relate to us that this is the very first time the eleven witness the risen Jesus, and this occurs in Jerusalem. Furthermore, during this encounter Jesus orders the disciples not to leave Jerusalem until a certain event is to have occurred:

49 And behold, I am sending the promise of my Father upon you. But stay in the city until you are clothed with power from on high.”

The book of Acts, which is widely regarded to belong to a single composite work by the same author, often called "Luke-Acts", reaffirms the previous command of Jesus in Luke towards the apostles to remain in Jerusalem, Acts 1:

4 And while staying with them he ordered them not to depart from Jerusalem, but to wait for the promise of the Father, which, he said, “you heard from me; 5 for John baptized with water, but you will be baptized with the Holy Spirit not many days from now.”

We know that the disciples did not receive the Holy Spirit until after the Ascension of the resurrected Jesus, as told in Acts chapter 2. Therefore according to the author of Luke, from the moment of Jesus' first appearance to the eleven disciples, up until to his Ascension, they never left Jerusalem.

On the other hand, the author of Matthew states the following, Matthew 28:

8 So they departed quickly from the tomb with fear and great joy, and ran to tell his disciples. 9 And behold, Jesus met them and said, “Greetings!” And they came up and took hold of his feet and worshiped him. 10 Then Jesus said to them, “Do not be afraid; go and tell my brothers to go to Galilee, and there they will see me.”

The women at the tomb run off to tell the disciples of the empty tomb, and suddenly meet Jesus. This occurs immediately after the angels appear at the tomb. None of Jesus' followers had seen the resurrected Jesus before this point. Contrary to Luke however, where the eleven first meet Jesus in Jerusalem, Jesus says here he will meet them in Galilee. Now, this would have been resolved if these disciples were other than the eleven, however we know that he is referring to the eleven:

16 Now the eleven disciples went to Galilee, to the mountain to which Jesus had directed them. 17 And when they saw him they worshiped him, but some doubted.

According to the author of Matthew, the eleven first encounter the risen Jesus in Galilee. This is exemplified in the doubt of some of the eleven. Of course we are not given elaborate descriptions of their reactions like in Luke, but if this would've been anything other than their first encounter then they wouldn't have doubted.

How is this supposed discrepancy resolved?

  • Related, possible duplicate, does this answer your question ? : Why are the four accounts of the tomb different ?. – Nigel J Oct 23 at 7:54
  • @NigelJ No. The question you linked is too general. Mine is very specific. – RandomUser Oct 23 at 9:40
  • There is also an excellent article giving a full breakdowm of the events and giving a diagram of the timeline. I do not wish to copy the entire article to here but I recommend it. The Sequence of Christ's Post-Resurrection Appearances. There is no contradiction once all the events are properly catalogued, as does the article. – Nigel J Oct 23 at 9:51
  • @NigelJ The article assumes that the appearance in Galilee occurs after the appearance in Jerusalem without any explanation other than that it must've occurred subsequently because it is more than a day's journey to Galilee, while the disciples were already in Jerusalem. Unconvincing to me, why? Because other details of this encounter are ignored. According to Matthew, Jesus told the women he would meet the disciples in Galilee. How could this be referring to anything other than the first time? Jesus says to meet him in Galilee, meets them in Jerusalem, then in Galilee? Odd order of events.. – RandomUser Oct 23 at 10:36
  • @NigelJ I disagree. I believe I have established very reasonably that there seems to be an incompatibility between the two accounts. – RandomUser Oct 23 at 11:21
0

Jesus appeared first to the 11 disciples (minus Thomas) in Jerusalem, in the meeting described in Luke 24:36-43 and John 20:19-25. See The Sequence of Christ’s Post-Resurrection Appearances (article reference courtersy of Nigel J). The chart shows that Jesus first appeared to them on the Easter day in Jerusalem, then in Galilee, then again in Jerusalem (this is when they were told to stay in Jerusalem to wait for the Pentecost).

For a more detailed (but straightforward) explanation of where first meeting took place, please see Go and Stay Discrepancy?. The key is to locate the Galilee appearance in the space between Luke 24:43 and Luke 24:44, because

... it is a merely an assumption to assert that Jesus spoke Luke 24:44ff on Easter Day.

| improve this answer | |
  • I find this to be the only possible answer, but not without its difficulties. It's hard to believe that when Jesus tells the women at the tomb "go and tell my brothers to go to Galilee, and there they will see me" that what he actually means is "tell them they will see me in Galilee, but they will actually see me first in Jerusalem then in Galilee", Matthew and Mark seem to portray this as the very first time the disciples are to meet Jesus. – RandomUser Oct 24 at 19:35
  • Furthermore, John 21:14 says "This was now the third time that Jesus was revealed to the disciples after he was raised from the dead." So according to John the disciples met Jesus in Galilee only on the third time! And not even on the prescribed mountain in Matthew, but on the seashore of the Tiberias lake. – RandomUser Oct 24 at 20:12
  • @RandomUser Wouldn't "my brothers" in Matt 28:10 refer to Jesus's biological brothers, not the 11 apostles? If that's the case, I don't see anymore issues and the timeline graphic in Nigel's Sequence article is consistent with the "Go and Stay Discrepancy" explanation. The same chart also shows that the Tiberias meeting was the 3rd time. The Galilee mountain meeting was the 4th time. – GratefulDisciple Oct 25 at 0:11

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.