0

In my Interlinear bible, the words 'ye may be healed' come under one Greek word iaomai (Strongs No G2390) to cure, heal, make whole. For some, adding the word may introduces some doubt, ie may or may not be healed. Why did the translators add these words to to this verse and not to any others were the word healed is used.

  • 1
    Welcome to BHSX. Thanks for your question. Please remember to take the tour (link below) to better understand how this site works. – Dottard Sep 26 at 11:13
  • Is this a question about Greek grammar, or about English grammar? – TRiG Sep 26 at 20:15
4

This is a simple grammatical question that is resolved by understanding how the Greek works.

Greek is a highly inflected language, especially the verbs. The verb in question here is: ἰάομαι (iaomai) = "I heal", in its lexical form; however, in James 5:16 it occurs in the form ἰαθῆτε (iathēte) = Verb - Aorist Subjunctive Passive - 2nd Person Plural; and so must be translated, "you [plural] may be healed".

Because of the versatility and inflection in the Greek verbs, pronouns are only rarely needed because the verb contains all that is required to convey the meaning. This is a perfect example where the pronouns have not been used but the sense is perfectly clear.

Lastly, note that the "mood" of the verb is "subjunctive" and the "voice" is "passive", that is why it must be translated with a "may" and that the action is not done by the subject.

Your translation is quite valid and every other version will show something similar.

| improve this answer | |
  • Thank you, dose the word 'may' mean you will be healed or does it have an element of doubt in it? – Stephen Sep 28 at 8:05
  • @Stephen - it is the English method we have of expressing the subjunctive mood. It does NOT mean that a person "might" be healed, it expresses the idea that under these circumstances, the way is provided for healing. – Dottard Sep 28 at 11:11
  • Thank you very much. – Stephen Sep 28 at 15:29
2

Strongs No G2390 iaomai shows the lexicon (dictionary) spelling and meaning of a Greek word. When this word is used in James 5:16, it is spelled as iathēte. That is its subjunctive form. The Greek subjunctive mood primarily refers to HYPOTHETICAL actions in the PRESENT or FUTURE. In English we use the subjunctive mainly when talking about events that are not certain to happen.

Further, hopōs iathēte (so that you may be healed) forms potential subjunctive purpose clause. It is not 100% definite but it has that potential. The focus is on the positive potential.

That is why it is translated as 'may be healed' in James 5:16. The translators translate the lexicon meaning of the word plus its subjunctive mood.

In https://biblehub.com/james/5-16.htm, 25 out of 27 versions translated as 'may be healed'. It is the overwhelming consensus. Good News Translation has over-translated iathēte

So then, confess your sins to one another and pray for one another, so that you will be healed. The prayer of a good person has a powerful effect.

| improve this answer | |
  • Thank you Tony, can I ask, how did you find out that in James 5:16 the word healed is spelled as iathete? Also, when you say the actions in the Present or Future, but are they definite ? ie its going to happen, or in this case 'that you may or may not be healed. – Stephen Sep 28 at 8:22
  • I made modification. – Tony Chan Sep 28 at 16:15
1

Because this seems to have been the standard way of formulating expressions of this type in early modern English. The presence of the conjunction that modifies the auxiliary verb usually responsible for constructing the future tense, resulting in an(other) tense altogether, called conjunctive or subjunctive. (For more information, feel free to consult our two sister sites, Linguistics.SE and English.SE). Thus, within the traditional King James version, the statistical distribution is as follows:

  • that you/ye may appears 92 times,
  • that you/ye might appears 27 times,
  • that you/ye be appears eleven times,
  • that you/ye will appears seven times.

Similarly for other pronouns:

  • that I may appears 144 times,
  • that I will appears 66 times,
  • that I might appears 39 times,
  • that I be appears twice.

  • that (s)he may appears 103 times,
  • that (s)he might appears 69 times,
  • that (s)he will appears twenty times,
  • that (s)he be appears twice.

  • that we may appears 74 times,
  • that we might appears nineteen times,
  • that we will appears six times,
  • that we be appears twice.

  • that they may appears 155 times,
  • that they might appears 66 times,
  • that they be appears ten times,
  • that they will appears five times.

It follows that, by and large, the most frequent auxiliary verbs, in descending order of preference, are:

  • may, appearing (over) 568 times,
  • might, appearing (over) 220 times,
  • will, appearing (over) 104 times,
  • be, appearing (over) 27 times.

(The above is for pronouns only; other auxiliaries are shall, shalt, and should, for which the interested reader is invited to construct their own tables, using a biblical software of their own choice; personally, I have employed Theophilos).

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.