I was attracted to this site and forum because it appears to be serious, honest, and diligent. I found nothing redeeming in the responses I read; they appear to me to be "straining a gnat," too intellectual, non sequitur and askew of context. Let's dispense with the horizontal personal opinions of intellect and stick with the raw unfiltered vertical truth from the Father above. The context of verse 11 of Thes was completely avoided. The context is that delusion WILL BE SENT BY GOD ...if... one does not subscribe to the love of truth. This begs the question; what is love and what is truth?
First, to answer the question about delusion as to being causatively directed from our Father, without equivocating let's go to Isaiah and Job.
Isa 66:4 I also will choose their delusions, and will bring their fears upon them; because when I called, none did answer; when I spake, they did not hear: but they did evil before mine eyes, and chose that in which I delighted not.
Job 39:17 because God has caused her to forget wisdom, and He has not given her a share in understanding.
Job 39:18 At the time she lifts herself up on high, she scorns the HORSE and its RIDER.
As Thes suggests the context is love and truth so rather than going to earthly dictionaries or personal commentaries, again let's go to Him, His Truth and Word for definitions.
Psa 119:142 Your righteousness is an everlasting righteousness, and Your Law is the truth.
The law, the commandments is the truth. I won't say any more on that but now let's go to Romans 13:8-10.
Rom 13:8 Owe no one anything, except to love one another; for he who loves another has fulfilled the Law.
Rom 13:9 For: "Do not commit adultery; do not murder; do not steal; do not bear false witness; do not lust;" and if there is any other commandment, it is summed up in this word, "You shall love your neighbor as yourself."
Rom 13:10 Love works no ill to its neighbor, therefore love is the fulfilling of the Law.
The law and love are woven together like a singular rug. The woof doesn't exist without the warp. Paul says that to love one another means to fulfill the commandments; Jesus says the same exact thing in Mt. 5. It is a logical question to ask now, does spiritual love exist today? Without equivocating, NO. Heaven and earth have not passed away an neither has the law. In fact, the execution of spiritual laws hasn't even begun and it won't begin until we reach the 1000 year SPIRITUAL AGE, the Millennial Kingdom (MK). Today we have lots of kindness that we call love and then we have much more madness. I suppose someone will counter with the supposition of the number of types of Greek love there may be but I will take that argument up if I get it.
I want to approach the answer to delusion indirectly through the mysteries that lie beneath the literal text in the verses I have quoted above. We are admonished in Mt 13 to seek the mysteries of the kingdom by Jesus. What are the mysteries and how can we know them? This is a very short answer to an extremely large subject.
The Parable of the Sower (POTS) and the 30-60-100 fruit is a pattern and paradigm that allows one to see the mysteries of the kingdom. As Mark says, all the parables are understood if you know what the 30-60-100 paradigm metaphors are. The wayside stony and thorny seed do not produce any spiritual fruit; they go down to the pit. The THREE good seeds enter the kingdom of heaven (KH). Now we tie this 'three' spiritual seeds paradigm to Mt. 13:33. Leaven (sin) is likened, compared to the three remaining good seeds of Mt. 13:8 and 23. The seeds are metaphors for people groups, three of them. The KH is defined as having three groups of sinners for all have "fallen short..."
Backing up a couple verses in Mt 13 we have the parable of the M Seed. The abbreviated meaning of this parable is that we enter the Mil Kingdom (MK) metaphorically with the spiritual stature of a tiny seed. When the light and the life from above comes down in the MK the seed sprouts and we continue to spiritually mature to that of the stature of a tree where the birds rest in it. The birds are angels but we have to leave that alone for now. The MK is about 1000 years of spiritual growth with all the blessings of love and joy that are unimaginable.
Next we go to Mt. 25 and parable of the talents where we get a second witness of THREE believers that enter the KH. Two of the servants are praised while the third is labeled wicked and lazy. Not only is he wicked but he must give up his single talent to him who has ten talents; this is a submission posture and paradigm. This is critical: the two talent and five talent servants doubled their respective talents and are blessed with being rewarded as RULERS OF MANY THINGS. When? In the 1000 year MK! The question remains, why or what defines wicked and lazy? Can we know? Of course; all Scripture answers Scripture. In fact, once you know how to SEE and HEAR the mysteries and paradigms (it is actually quite simple) of this threefold phenomena then one is able to see these questions answered multiple thousands of times beginning all the way back in the first verse of Genesis. In the few OT verses I randomly quoted (I didn't front load by cherry picking) there are several 30-60-100 mystery paradigms with emphasis on the 60 and 100 folds, the rulers of many things (Mt. 25:23, 25).
The next most important and third witness is found in Ezekiel 44. Ezekiel qualifies who the 30-60-100 are. This book explains who will be in the Millennial Kingdom (MK) based on our rewards of our current life. It also explains to some extent what the two rulers of many will be doing for 1000 years.
The 100 fold are the priests of the MK that God chooses. The 60 fold are what Ezekiel calls the Levite but in the MK there won't be a Levitical tribe but they will be called prophets. The 60 fold are the elect 144,000 who are covenanted in this present kingdom age. Both the 100 fold and 60 fold are covenanted to the Father but the 30 fold group, the MULTITUDE are not covenanted and this is why they are called wicked and lazy. Ezekiel 44 explains in verses 4-9 why the 30 fold is not covenanted.
I can't go into great detail here but in the two verses of Job there are two glaring threefold paradigms; I will just underscore the rudimentary aspects of this spiritual principle. Sorting out who the 60 and 100 fold are and why is critical to understanding why the 30 fold lazy group is struck with delusion.
Job 39:17 because God has caused her to forget wisdom, and He has not given her a share in understanding.
Job 39:18 At the time she lifts herself up on high, she scorns the HORSE and its RIDER.
In verse 17 wisdom and understanding are highlighted and are 100 and 60 fold respectively. The third or 30 fold group appears left out but not so; the 30 fold is visible in the pronoun 'her.' This 'her' would also be the equivalent of knowledge. In other words, 30 fold knowledge leads to 60 fold understanding and more diligence then renders one with 100 fold wisdom or part of the priesthood. This is what the mysteries teach us untold thousands of times. Even a casual glance at Psalms and Proverbs one can see this paradigm.
In the poetic writings, particularly Job, Psalms and the prophets, pronouns of her, she and nouns of harlot(ry), whoredom, and adjectives of wicked, evil, abominations etc are used prolifically. These references are never (or rarely) used except to point to the 30 fold spiritual harlot. Now back to delusion.
Notice in verse 17 how it is God that causes the 30 fold spiritual harlot not only to not have 100 fold wisdom blessings, but not have a 60 fold understanding of spiritual matters. The spiritual harlot knows(ledge{30fold}) that there is a God but they are bereft of His blessing. They are not covenanted so He sends them strong delusion because they fail to have the love for the truth. Elsewhere in the Word the 30 fold are known as the multitude, children, or the sand of the sea.
In verse 18 the same paradigm exists but with different metaphors; this time she (30), horse (100) and rider (60). Where have we seen the horse and the rider paradigm before. In 2 Kings chariots of fire and horses of fire separated Elijah who went up from Elisha who stayed below. Do you see the pattern? Chariots are always 60 and horses always represent the 100 fold. The 30 fold group is there in that setting but they are standing across the Jordan watching all this transpire. What is the spiritual contextual meaning of this account? Elijah, a 100 fold priest is being chosen and separated unto Himself (Dt.18:5). This will happen in the twinkling of an eye when we cross over to the MK.
In virtually every verse throughout the poetic writings, this and many more paradigms play out beneath the surface of the literal text. Each verse presents the same or similar paradigm but with different metaphors. I walked for many years in the dark bereft of the light, love, and truth; once I turned back, and immediately, God began blessing me first with understanding and then followed wisdom. I wish the same for you. I would love to share more but this is all I have time for.
Shalom
(No time for a proper answer!)
- OK, I took the time. ;)