Reputation
1,124
Top tag
Next privilege 1,250 Rep.
Create tag synonyms
Badges
1 7 22
Impact
~117k people reached

Apr
11
revised What does Cain say to Abel in Genesis 4:8?
it is a grammar error, which is a form of contradiction for such things
Apr
11
comment Was Moses the probable author of Genesis?
@BruceAlderman: I agree you need someone to tell you, and then you notice, but once you notice, if you reject it, this is is a lie to yourself and to others. I read Gen/Exo, and the E,J doublets, along with the textual divisions, are absolutely manifest to the eyes. I can't condone people who read this text and don't say so. It's like half is in caps and the other half small.
Apr
11
awarded  Quorum
Apr
11
asked Is the author of Ecclesiastes referring to Archimedes?
Apr
11
comment Why does God say he only revealed his name, Yahweh, to Moses?
@J.C.Salomon: Whether it's "with" or "in" (I used "by"), the best reading by far is that the Patriarchs were not given the name. This is E narrative, it is consistent with E narrative in other ways. It is a little more plausible using "with my YHVH-ness", but the word used is "with my YHWH name" (I would use "in my guise of YHWH" as the closest corresponding ambiguous English construction to your intended interpretation). Even this way, it sounds most naturally like "I did not reveal my name". Your interpretation is the same as the upvoted answer--- I don't think it is supported by the text.
Apr
11
accepted Why does Moses grill leavened bread on Yahweh's altar?
Apr
11
comment Why does Moses grill leavened bread on Yahweh's altar?
+1: Thanks much! This completely answers the question.
Apr
11
accepted Did Noah take two doves, or fourteen?
Apr
11
accepted Was Abimelech a granny chaser?
Apr
11
comment Why does God say he only revealed his name, Yahweh, to Moses?
@J.C.Salomon: You are right. I chose a new wording. Sorry. I make mistakes like that every once in a while. Thanks for catching it.
Apr
11
revised Why does God say he only revealed his name, Yahweh, to Moses?
fix
Apr
11
comment Why does God say he only revealed his name, Yahweh, to Moses?
@J.C.Salomon: I see now--- because the Hebrew is "in my name Yahweh, I did not make myself known", I translated equivalently to "my name Yahweh, I did not make known", because I thought the "in" business was too idiomatic Hebrew. I changed the phrasing to the easier English--- because the "in my guise of Yahweh, I did not make myself known" is much too cumbersome in my opinion for the simple Hebrew sentiment. I am asking about the Hebrew, not the English, which is just a gloss. If you think it's really wrong, I can fix it, but I think it's ok, in terms of matching with equal formality.
Apr
11
comment What is Leviticus 13:55 all about?
Please put the full verse, so one can see exactly what is being translated--- they might skip this part.
Apr
11
comment Why does Moses grill leavened bread on Yahweh's altar?
Come on--- they explicitly describe the unleavened stuff as "matza", and this is a "loaf of bread". Is a "loaf of bread" somehow understood as an uncooked mixture of flour and oil? That would answer the question, but it's impossible. Do you have more textual evidence that this is the correct interpretation? The mincha offering describes cooking flour and oil, and this mixture is not described anywhere as a "loaf", and it is certainly not "bread". The "loafs" in the showbread basket are leavened bread. "lechem" means leavened bread. It doesn't mean flour. I can't believe this. No way.
Apr
11
accepted Why is Beer-Sheva' called Beer-Sheva'?
Apr
11
accepted What is Leviticus 13:55 all about?
Apr
11
comment Was Moses the probable author of Genesis?
@JonEricson: The "concept of doublets" is so obvious in the text, it requires willful blindness to ignore. The "documentary hypothesis" is a certain fact, and it must be the starting point of reasoned conversation.
Apr
10
comment Is tola'at sheni a knit?
I see... so this is a scarlet dyed cloth. Got it. How certain is this identification? Has anyone made such worm-dyed cloth? how many worms per square meter? I'll accept the answer if it gives a confidence interval--- should I be 50%, 20%, 90%, or 99.99% certain of this identification?
Apr
10
awarded  Talkative
Apr
10
comment Why does God say he only revealed his name, Yahweh, to Moses?
@FrankLuke: I have seen this happen far too often with rabbinical commentary. So far, Maimonides is ok (I may be biased for obvious reasons), but Rashi always makes stuff up (like the abominable "Bro"), and he makes stuff up to support reasonable theology, but it is a disservice to the text. I get annoyed that people who know Hebrew, and know it well enough to know better, don't just read the plain text that they see, instead of embellishing it to push anachronistic theological positions that do not belong in the ancient text.