2,889 reputation
822
bio website
location
age
visits member for 1 year, 4 months
seen yesterday
stats profile views 30

please delete me


Apr
14
comment Who was Matthew 5-7 addressed to?
@jackdouglas I question the relevance. I'm just saying that the text of John never limits the group to the twelve. He only specifically addresses the twelve in the setting of John.
Apr
14
comment Who was Matthew 5-7 addressed to?
@joseph I believe you're straining the interpretation on Jn 6:66. I don't think that means that only the twelve remained.
Apr
14
comment Who was Matthew 5-7 addressed to?
@JackDouglas i read that "if" as "since" because he went ahead and described the parallels.
Apr
14
answered Who was Matthew 5-7 addressed to?
Apr
14
comment Who was Matthew 5-7 addressed to?
@JackDouglas ... Joseph made the claim in his first paragraph.
Apr
14
comment Who was Matthew 5-7 addressed to?
Additionally, your question betrays your bias. Joseph, I was wondering if you'd be willing to interact with other scholarly sources and, perhaps, justify the claim that the sermon on the mount and the sermon on the plain are the same event
Apr
13
comment How should James 2:18 be translated?
thanks @Mike - i appreciate that
Apr
13
comment How should James 2:18 be translated?
that's a lot of theology to read into a translation.
Apr
12
revised How should James 2:18 be translated?
added 147 characters in body
Apr
12
comment If a “house divided cannot stand” how did non-disciples cast out demons?
Jack, this is a good answer but there's nothing in the text itself that would lead one to believe that these deeds are invalid. The context of Matt. 7 is a family talk that Jesus is having with his disciples (Matt 5:1-2). You rightly note that the context of Luke is one of sign-seeking and some of those doubt the authority/ability of Jesus to do this. They look for some other authority for this miracle. I think we are pressing if we try too hard to harmonize these accounts instead of taking the lessons as we should from each of them.
Apr
12
comment How should James 2:18 be translated?
Punctuation is not part of the original text and the grammar of the source text lends itself to a degree of speculation. Please cut the weasel words "painfully" and "obvious" and the other filler ("I can't figure out ...") and shore up this answer a bit. You've missed a significant portion of the debate.
Apr
11
comment If a “house divided cannot stand” how did non-disciples cast out demons?
This is rooted in a false dilemma. This false dilemma is rooted in the insistence that those whom Jesus did not know are necessarily of Satan.
Apr
11
awarded  Civic Duty
Apr
11
comment Before the Tower of Babel did all speak Hebrew as the original human language?
Could you pleas explain the relevance of these observations to the question?
Apr
11
comment Why is the “give to Caesar what is Caesar's” answer so great?
I have attempted an edit on your question. The more I attempted to sort through what you were trying to say, the more I realized how much of it is really just a thinly-veiled ad hominem strawman argument. I agree with the ultimate conclusion (which you state near the beginning), but I also think that there's another answer that fits the format better.
Apr
11
revised Why is the “give to Caesar what is Caesar's” answer so great?
added 2 characters in body
Apr
11
revised Why is the “give to Caesar what is Caesar's” answer so great?
deleted 320 characters in body
Apr
10
awarded  Suffrage
Apr
10
awarded  Outspoken
Apr
10
reviewed No Action Needed Is Jesus equal to or less than the Father